We’re Demanding That Newsrooms Improve Their 2024 Election Coverage
Our democracy’s survival requires a newsroom reset.
On August 12, 2024 we sent the below open letter, along with our first batch of 3,000+ signatures, to the executives, publishers, and union leaders of major media organizations. It’s not too late to add your name and join us in demanding pro-democracy election coverage.
Open Letter
Dear American Media Executives, Publishers, and Journalists:
We need you to stand up for America. Our democracy is under attack. Despite being the only president in our history to attempt a coup, Donald Trump is again running for office in 2024 while publicly suggesting he would rule as a dictator. His anti-democratic behavior earns him endorsements from the majority of elected officials in his party.
Reporting facts, uplifting elections, and condemning violence is not partisan. In fact, a pro-democracy bias is crucial for the survival of our nation. We respectfully propose a set of guidelines for your 2024 election coverage below, emphasizing a switch in focus from polls and drama to policies, past-governance, and behavior.
COVER ELECTIONS LIKE THEY MATTER MORE THAN SPORTS SCORES
-
Prioritize substantive coverage of the issues that matter to voters' lives.
-
Make headlines accurate and informative, not clickbait.
-
Stop making predictions and pushing polls at the expense of issues coverage.
-
Celebrate and uplift election workers, voters, and the election process.
-
Don’t set aside moral judgment when covering obvious lies and bigotry.
-
Hold politicians to account for their positions, statements, and behavior, as well as those of their party’s leader.
MAKE THREATS TO DEMOCRACY CLEAR
-
Inform voters of the freedoms they will lose if the MAGA movement wins.
-
Abandon false equivalence between traditional and fascistic candidates.
-
Expose candidates who foment political violence.
-
Call out lies and bad behavior in every piece of reporting.
-
Prominently cover the Big Lie-fueled attack on election legitimacy and voting rights.
PROTECT AMERICANS FROM DISINFORMATION
-
Avoid euphemisms that conceal and normalize extremism.
-
Explain that disinformation by MAGA is a strategy.
-
Don’t platform liars or act as stenographers for strategic MAGA lies.
-
Include a public figure’s history of coup participation when quoting them.
-
Inoculate Americans against a repeat of the Big Lie strategy.
-
Build public trust by explaining the newsroom decisions you make about elections.
-
Have a plan for handling deepfakes.
Voters need to know what Trump and his allies are planning to do with power, and about the damaging impact their lies have already had on the health of our democracy. For example, a spike in death threats following lies about the 2020 election has led to difficulties in recruiting and retaining poll workers. Half of all female state legislators in the country are considering leaving public office in the face of increased threats. Trump allies are readying plans like Project 2025, which would harm millions of Americans and break our democratic system.
Please do not treat the 2024 presidential election and down ballot races as traditional choices between Democratic and Republican candidates. Elections are now contests between those willing to uphold our democratic system and those trying to break it using violence, deceit, and intimidation. As Thomas Mann and Norm Ornstein warn: “balanced treatment of an unbalanced phenomenon distorts reality.”
We are in grave and accelerating danger as a country. The rights and freedoms that Americans cherish are at risk. As an essential pillar of democracy, you have a moral responsibility to inform Americans about anti-democratic extremist movements and lies with the prominence and frequency this moment demands. If you do not, America will likely wake up to authoritarian rule on January 21, 2025.
Informative, brave journalism is required for our nation to overcome this assault. We strongly recommend you calibrate your political coverage to adopt and adhere to practices that are pro-truth, pro-voting, and pro-democracy.
We are rooting for you.
Sincerely,
The Media and Democracy Project
Distinguished Signers:
David Armiak, Center for Media and Democracy
Ruth Ben-Ghiat, Professor of History
Mabel Berezin, Professor of Sociology
Brooke Binkowski, Journalist
Ron Bishop, Professor of Communication
Andrea Chalupa, Gaslit Nation
Eric Chenoweth, Director, Institute for Democracy in Eastern Europe
Jessica Craven, Chop Wood, Carry Water
Heidi Cuda, Journalist, Emmy-award winner
Bonnie Fuller, Contributing Writer, Ms Magazine & Courier Newsroom
Carlissia Graham, President, New Media Ventures
Micheline Ishay, Professor of International Studies and Human Rights
Mark Jacob, Former Editor Chicago Tribune
Jeff Jarvis, Director, Tow-Knight Center for Entrepreneurial Journalism
Michael Krasner, Professor of Political Science
Nancy MacLean, Professor of History and Public Policy
Irving Markovitz, Professor of Political Science
Robert McChesney, Professor of Communication, co-founder Free Press
Michael Meeropol, Professor of Economics
Norm Ornstein, Political Scientist
Arn Pearson, Center for Media and Democracy
David Pepper, Author, Laboratories of Autocracy
Victor Pickard, Professor of Media Policy and Political Economy
Maria Puerta, Professor of Political Science
Sylvia Salazar, Tono Latino
Jason Sattler, Journalist
Jen Senko, Media Activist, "The Brainwashing of My Dad"
Meredith Shiner, Media Strategist and former National Political Reporter
Sue Wilson, Journalist, Media Action Center
Adding your organization will be considered confirmation that you are authorized to sign on its behalf.
Guidelines
In 2024, American newsrooms have a responsibility to:
COVER ELECTIONS LIKE THEY MATTER MORE THAN SPORTS SCORES
-
Prioritize substantive coverage of the issues that matter to voters' lives.
-
Make headlines accurate and informative, not clickbait.
-
Stop making predictions and pushing polls at the expense of issues coverage.
-
Celebrate and uplift election workers, voters, and the election process.
-
Don’t set aside moral judgment when covering obvious lies and bigotry.
-
Hold politicians to account for their positions, statements, and behavior, as well as those of their party’s leader.
Prioritize substantive coverage of the issues that matter to voters' lives. Democracy is not a sport to be treated like entertainment. Decisions made by elected officials can mean life or death. Newsrooms focus their election coverage much too heavily on the odds of victory (the “horse race”), when they should be giving the public crucial context on the stakes. Americans need to know about policies and their impacts, not insider politics. Tell us if a candidate holds extreme views on abortion, what their solutions are for gun deaths, whether their environmental policies will mitigate or exacerbate the climate emergency, all while providing context from experts on what solutions are most worth pursuing. Marvin Kalb put it perfectly for the Brookings Institution in 2021: “reporters should…start explaining the substantial problems currently bedeviling America and then presenting possible solutions, as suggested by Democrats and Republicans, ultimately leaving it to the American voter to decide what’s best...”
Make headlines accurate and informative, not clickbait. Your newsrooms choose specific words and phrases for headlines because they are known to increase engagement. Some outlets employ A/B testing to optimize headlines with the same goal in mind. This deeply cynical, profit-seeking approach to informing the public is antithetical to the premise of journalism. The frames chosen for headlines affect how a reader processes the information in an article. Make sure your headlines do not contain euphemism or emotive terms at the expense of truth and reality. Be clear about the anti-democratic behavior we are witnessing.
Stop making predictions and pushing polls at the expense of issues coverage. We are awash in speculation about campaign strategies and election outcomes. Yet most of the time the media speculates, it gets things very wrong. Predictions crowd out the substantive information voters need to make decisions in their self-interest. Excessive polling coverage gives the impression that the horse race is more important than the potential loss of democracy. Substance-free coverage obscures the reality that the Republican party is setting swing states up to have free and fair votes overturned. That’s the story!
Celebrate and uplift election workers, voters, and the election process. Center and humanize those behind the scenes - election officials and workers who make sure elections are conducted with accuracy. They are facing threats of violence, many quitting, following strategic MAGA Republican attacks. Spotlight and celebrate election workers so they don’t remain abstracted and easier to demonize. Drop paywalls for election coverage. Write a how-to guide for voting and pin the digital version to the top of your homepage. Explain how to get involved in local politics and elections. Democratize your newsroom by establishing a citizen’s agenda - ask voters about the coverage they need as they head to the polls. Make your newsroom a one-stop shop for voters in your community.
Don’t set aside your moral judgment when covering obvious lies and bigotry. It’s immoral to normalize liars and racists when you know they are those things. A candidate’s pursuit of a political office does not give them automatic legitimacy or excuse them from adhering to basic norms of society and democratic politics. Be like the Wisconsin Examiner and call out a renowned liar and bigot when he employs Nazi rhetoric.
Hold politicians to account for their positions, statements, and behavior, as well as those of their party’s leader. It is important to get politicians on the record about the actions and standing of their party leader at all times, but especially in an election year. If a candidate at the top of a major party ticket has been found liable for rape, has a history of financial fraud, and refuses to honor the results of free and fair elections, the members of that candidate’s party should be put on record answering where they stand on that behavior.
MAKE THREATS TO DEMOCRACY CLEAR
-
Inform voters of the freedoms they will lose if the MAGA movement wins.
-
Abandon false equivalence between traditional and fascistic candidates.
-
Expose candidates who foment political violence.
-
Call out lies and bad behavior in every piece of reporting.
-
Prominently cover the Big Lie-fueled attack on election legitimacy and voting rights.
Inform voters of the freedoms they will lose if the MAGA movement wins. Voters need to know who stands to gain and who will suffer if an openly fascistic candidate, with the support of nearly all electeds in his party, prevails. We can expect the loss of rights, more corruption, more pollution, degradation of government services, loss of Medicare and Social Security, imposition of a state-sponsored religion, criminalizing of peaceful protest, further restrictions on voting - in essence a locking in of authoritarian, anti-democratic power with virtually no accountability. Kudos to The Atlantic for sounding an appropriate level of alarm by devoting their January issue to the consequences of a Trump victory; we need more of this type of reporting. Threats to our democracy and well-being demand constant attention from all media until they are common knowledge.
Abandon false equivalence between traditional and fascistic candidates. For example, treating traditional Kamala Harris and fascistic Donald Trump as having comparable but different visions for America is a distortion. It was a mistake for newsrooms to falsely make Biden’s gaffes out to be as monumental as Trump’s coup attempt, election lies, sexual assault, or fascist plans. Maintaining this false equivalence now that Harris is at the top of the Democratic ticket normalizes the obscene and boosts an anti-democracy candidate.. As Robert Reich wrote ahead of the 2022 midterms: "It is dangerous to believe that ‘balanced journalism’ gives equal weight to liars and to truth-tellers, to those intent on destroying democracy and those seeking to protect it…"
Expose candidates who foment political violence. Normalizing politicians who tell xenophobic and racist lies about pivotal issues increases the likelihood of political violence. One purpose of telling election lies is to foment unrest ahead of November that could have a chilling effect on turnout. Intimidation is likely to play a role as voters head to the polls and beleaguered election workers try to do their jobs. Clearly name and condemn all forms of violence and intimidation directed at public officials and groups historically suppressed from exercising full voting rights.
Call out lies and bad behavior in every piece of reporting. Any reporting that ignores a candidate’s history of lies and criminality, or their attempts to destroy American democracy, is disrespectful to the public. 70% of Republican voters do not believe Joe Biden won the 2020 election because the MAGA wing of the Republican party lies to America. You make these lies seem legitimate, and their impact tolerable, by ignoring them to focus on polls and predictions. You render the reprehensible acceptable whenever you report on Trump as though he’s just another candidate, without including the breadth of his disqualifying behavior–that a judge determined he raped someone, that he’s been found liable for massive fraud, and his COVID pandemic failures that cost hundreds of thousands of American lives..
Prominently cover the Big Lie-fueled attack on election legitimacy and voting rights. Comprehensively describe and condemn threats to free and fair elections and the peaceful transfer of power. MAGA Republicans are strategically lying so they can make it harder to vote and ignore the will of the people if they lose. Their election fraud lies create public distrust, manufacturing public outcry that is then used as pretense to pass baseless voter suppression laws. Don’t indulge this anti-American attack. You have a moral imperative to speak accurately about strategies to derail our electoral infrastructure. Do not run from this responsibility, as CNN did under Chris Licht.
-
Avoid euphemisms that conceal and normalize extremism.
-
Explain that disinformation by MAGA is a strategy.
-
Don’t platform liars or act as stenographers for strategic MAGA lies.
-
Include a public figure’s history of coup participation when quoting them.
-
Inoculate Americans against a repeat of the Big Lie strategy.
-
Build public trust by explaining the newsroom decisions you make about elections.
-
Have a plan for handling deepfakes.